Skip to content
Scratch and Dent, Ex-Display, B-Stock: What to Call Stock You Can't Sell as New

Scratch and Dent, Ex-Display, B-Stock: What to Call Stock You Can't Sell as New

Open box is an electronics word.

If you sell speakers, laptops or cameras, you already use it. You have probably built a page for it on your Shopify store. The term arrived with consumer electronics, and Amazon and Best Buy made it standard.

If you sell anything else, the category has been quietly telling you it is not for you. And that is a problem, because the thing it describes is sitting in the back of almost every warehouse in retail.

The same shelf, eight different names

Walk into different businesses and ask what they call the stock they cannot sell as new. You get a different answer every time.

Furniture retailers say scratch and dent. Appliance dealers say the same, or dented, or blemished. Showrooms and lighting stores say ex-display or floor model. Apparel brands say seconds, or B-grade, or factory seconds. Industrial and trade suppliers say as-is, or shelf pull, or salvage. Electronics says open box and refurbished. Almost everyone eventually says overstock or clearance, usually incorrectly, because those describe new goods that did not sell rather than goods that came back.

The vocabulary is different. The shelf is identical. A unit came back from a customer, or came off a showroom floor, or arrived with a mark on it. It works. It cannot go out as new. And it is worth real money to a buyer who does not mind.

The word you use decides whether you find help

Here is where the vocabulary stops being cosmetic.

We went through the Shopify App Store in late August, running the searches a merchant would actually type when they go looking for a way to sell this stock. Thirty four searches, then every listing that came back.

Search open box and you get a real set of results. Four apps compete for it. Search refurbished and you get a small but genuine set. Both of those terms are served.

Then search the rest. Scratch and dent returns nothing relevant at all, the results are scratch-card popups and colour swatch apps. Ex-display matches apps whose names begin with EX. B-stock matches back-in-stock alert tools. Factory seconds matches anything with Factory in the name. Damaged inventory returns forecasting software. Liquidation returns nothing useful because the search tokenises against Liquid, Shopify's own template language.

So a furniture retailer with two hundred dented units goes looking once, finds nothing that speaks their language, and concludes there is no answer for their kind of business. There is. It is the same answer the electronics stores are already using. The word was the only thing in the way.

The label is the price

Vocabulary matters a second time, on the listing itself.

Look at what the retailers who take this seriously actually do. Best Buy grades its open box stock into four named tiers, Excellent Certified, Excellent, Satisfactory and Fair, and publishes what each one means, so a shopper knows what a scratch is going to look like before they buy. eBay runs Certified Open Box through vetted sellers and attaches a full year of warranty to the ones that qualify, with thirty day free returns.

Neither of those is generosity. Both are pricing decisions. A graded unit with a described flaw sells for more than an ungraded unit with a vague one, because the buyer is no longer guessing.

Most independent stores do the opposite. Everything that came back goes into one bucket with one word on it, usually used or open box, and the whole shelf gets priced against the worst thing in it.

That is the expensive part. A refurbished unit has had more work done to it than a sealed one ever did. Somebody opened it, tested it, replaced the part that failed and checked it again. If it goes out with the same one word label as a scuffed box that was never opened, that labour is invisible at checkout, and you price it as though it never happened.

What a real condition description contains

There is no mystery to this. A description that earns a higher price has four things in it.

A grade, from a scale you use consistently. Whatever the scale is, use the same one every time so a repeat buyer learns what your words mean.

What is actually wrong, specifically. Not "minor cosmetic wear". A two inch scuff on the lower left corner of the base. A crushed box with the product untouched. A missing wall adapter.

What was done to it. Tested. Cleaned. Part replaced. Repackaged. If your team spent an hour on it, that hour belongs in the listing.

Photographs of the actual unit. Not the catalogue image. The real one, with the real mark, from an angle that shows it.

Honest beats generous

The instinct is to undersell the flaw so the unit moves. It backfires.

A buyer who receives something worse than described opens a dispute, leaves a review, or asks for a return, and now you are handling the same unit twice. A buyer who receives exactly what the listing promised, including the scuff they already saw a photo of, keeps it.

This is the one thing an independent store can do that the biggest retailers structurally cannot. At their volume, a returned unit gets one word from a four item dropdown. You know the actual item. You can photograph the actual scratch and write the two sentences that explain it. Shoppers trust that more than a grade, and it produces fewer disputes on the other end.

Where the described unit belongs

None of this works if the listing sits somewhere nobody looks.

The shopper who would happily take a dented unit at a discount is usually the same shopper who just landed on the full price product page, searched for that exact item, and found the price higher than they wanted. If the graded unit lives on a separate clearance section, that shopper never learns it exists. We wrote about where shoppers actually arrive in a separate post on the product page.

Put the graded unit on the product page it came from, underneath the new one. Then the grade, the photos and the honest notes are doing their work in front of the person most likely to act on them.

So what do you call yours?

If you have a shelf of it in the back, it has a name in your business already. Scratch and dent. Ex-display. Seconds. B-stock. The name does not matter as much as what comes after it.

Grade it. Describe what is actually wrong. Say what you did to it. Photograph the real thing. Then put it where the buyer is standing.

Stop writing returns off. DRIP by Returns For Sale relists your returned, open box, scratch and dent, ex-display and refurbished stock on your own product pages, with real photos and an honest condition grade, drops the price a little each day until it sells, and removes the listing automatically when it does. No subscription, no setup fee, and your first 30 days are commission-free.

Get the App

Cart 0

Your cart is currently empty.

Start Shopping